Guild icon
Tulpa.info
Meta / metaphysics
This is the channel for the discussion of metaphysical and parapsychological subjects. Please keep discussion of these topics to this channel and out of the rest of the server.
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/25/2021 7:58 PM
and that's how I feel about free will 🤣
That's exactly what the post you quoted is saying
7:58 PM
Roger only uses the words "free will" in the context of the feeling of free will that persists even after "we see that we're not the doer"
Avatar
vͮiͥxͯiͥeͤ | 👻 BOT 2/25/2021 7:59 PM
I mean were made of the deterministic stuff so we are the doer
8:00 PM
the were not the doer thing only applies if you think there's some spooky-wooky soul like thing that isn't MADE of the machinery
Avatar
I'm not a human doing, I'm a human being 😀
💜 1
Avatar
vͮiͥxͯiͥeͤ | 👻 BOT 2/25/2021 8:01 PM
I know this is the wrong channel to say that in, feel a little like I just shouted "hail Satan!" in a baptist church
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/25/2021 8:01 PM
XDD
Avatar
Avatar
vͮiͥxͯiͥeͤ | 👻
I mean were made of the deterministic stuff so we are the doer
Unfastened Belts 2/25/2021 8:02 PM
As I said yesterday, that's not how human beings think of themselves though. You don't think of yourself as "I am a set of neurons and muscles being moved by the laws of physics"
Avatar
vͮiͥxͯiͥeͤ | 👻 BOT 2/25/2021 8:03 PM
I sure do!!
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/25/2021 8:03 PM
Well, then good for you 🙂
8:04 PM
As I've said before, it sounds like you're pretty comfortable with where you're at in life, which is all these pointers are trying to accomplish, anyway
Avatar
vͮiͥxͯiͥeͤ | 👻 BOT 2/25/2021 8:04 PM
I came loaded for bear, and now we're having a picnic? What the hell Marissa, I can't eat shotgun slugs, lol.
8:05 PM
I mean technically bear is supposedly terrible eating anyway I've heard
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/25/2021 8:05 PM
I would argue that seeing yourself as a set of neurons and muscles is exactly what's described when teachings say "you are not the doer"
Avatar
Avatar
vͮiͥxͯiͥeͤ | 👻
I mean technically bear is supposedly terrible eating anyway I've heard
Unfastened Belts 2/25/2021 8:05 PM
I've heard that bear paws were considered a delicacy in the old West
Avatar
vͮiͥxͯiͥeͤ | 👻 BOT 2/25/2021 8:06 PM
maybe, but what was the culinary standard back then? 😬🤣
Avatar
When you're hungry you'll eat anything.
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/25/2021 8:07 PM
lol fair enough
Avatar
Just ask the Donner Party (edited)
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 7:28 AM
@Deleted User So I think if I'm translating Roger correctly, then "dissociation" is what we've been discussing as the "awakening" state of "impersonal witnessing", whereas "flow state" is what's described as integration/liberation - the end of identity-based uncomfortableness with life
7:28 AM
"Flow state" is what he describes as "being lived" by life
7:30 AM
Roger's teacher used to say "the ego doesn't die - the human being is an ego, meaning a body/mind instrument ("robot") through which consciousness (awareness + "beingness") functions. Before integration, there is an ego with a belief in personal doership and attachment to outcomes, afterwards there is an ego without a belief in personal doership and attachment to outcomes" (edited)
7:31 AM
His teacher Ramesh Balsekar was the retired president of the Bank of India
Avatar
Avatar
Unfastened Belts
"Flow state" is what he describes as "being lived" by life
so what does he mean by flow state?
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:32 PM
Well he doesn't use that word, I'm saying that the way you use it sounds similar to how he describes the life experience after integration of the "impersonal witnessing" aspect with the body/mind aspect
10:32 PM
Whereas the "impersonal witnessing" or "awakening" state prior to integration with the body sounds more like what you call dissociation
Avatar
hmm i wouldn't use flow state in anything like that it's a bit different because it requires you to be focused and absorbed on a task to the point you are not focused on being here and now
10:34 PM
but big part of it is that you need to be hyperfocused on a challenging task
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:35 PM
From Roger's descriptions, being focused and absorbed in a task can is being present with the here-now. Even after integration, life remains practical. Integration is letting the functional thoughts that are not suffering come back in (whereas in the "witnessing" state, there are usually no thoughts at all)
10:36 PM
Doing math homework with no suffering is to be present with the here/now
Avatar
In positive psychology, a flow state, also known colloquially as being in the zone, is the mental state in which a person performing some activity is fully immersed in a feeling of energized focus, full involvement, and enjoyment in the process of the activity. In essence, flow is characterized by the complete absorption in what one does, and a resulting transformation in one's sense of time.
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:36 PM
Hmm fair enough I can see the difference
Avatar
so big part of it is that your time is distorted
10:37 PM
when you are grounded and you are here and now you don't feel that i think
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:37 PM
"Flow state" to me sounds like "the absence of obstacles" (i. e. suffering thoughts)
Avatar
oh oki i see what you mean
10:37 PM
so it's like you are just flowing without problems
10:37 PM
in how you used it
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:38 PM
Yeah
10:38 PM
Regardless whether you're studying for your maths finals, or sitting on a garden bench
10:38 PM
I think it's normal that "time flows differently" when you're studying for maths finals
Avatar
so this shows well what they describe as flow
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:39 PM
Yeah
Avatar
it means that your skill is high and challenge level is high and other thing is that you have immediate feedback
10:40 PM
i'm not sure if it is also used in learning mathematics
10:40 PM
because you are learning skill rather than using it
10:40 PM
it might be the case but i don't know
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:40 PM
Btw Roger sometimes says "boredom is a mild form of suffering" (expectation for circumstance to be more stimulating)
Avatar
i can see that
10:41 PM
isn't it how prisons work
10:41 PM
they punish people by boredom
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:41 PM
I would almost say that arousal/flow/control/relaxation = no suffering, boredom/apathy/worry/anxiety = suffering haha
10:42 PM
they punish people by boredom
The point is that you could go to prison with nothing to do, but not find yourself bored because being still isn't seen as inefficient
(edited)
Avatar
i think you are right
Avatar
Avatar
Unfastened Belts
@Deleted User So I think if I'm translating Roger correctly, then "dissociation" is what we've been discussing as the "awakening" state of "impersonal witnessing", whereas "flow state" is what's described as integration/liberation - the end of identity-based uncomfortableness with life
marissa so when you say dissociation in psychology dissociation can mean different things so some of them are derealisation depersonalisation dissociative amnesia dissociation from identity and i wonder if you know which one he means so what i think would fit here would be dissociation from your identity and making a vacuum for a new identity to form driven by the years of forcing that you were doing (edited)
10:45 PM
forcing meaning the framework sorry i used tulpa word here because it fits (edited)
10:46 PM
depersonalisation is when you still keep who you are but you see your body doing it's things dissociate from identity you can still experience being but you don't have anything that makes you you
10:48 PM
you can also dissociate without that experience of being
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:50 PM
Ah interesting
Avatar
from your descriptions i think he means the identity
Avatar
Avatar
Unfastened Belts
Roger's teacher used to say "the ego doesn't die - the human being is an ego, meaning a body/mind instrument ("robot") through which consciousness (awareness + "beingness") functions. Before integration, there is an ego with a belief in personal doership and attachment to outcomes, afterwards there is an ego without a belief in personal doership and attachment to outcomes" (edited)
also about this i think what he means with that is that ego is separate from identity and when you dissociate from identity then the ego will be what is still there to experience itself
10:54 PM
but i might be wrong
10:54 PM
but from our experience you can just dissolve and just not be aware of anything and body doesn't do anything
10:54 PM
not aware and no experience
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 10:54 PM
Yeah that's definitely how he says it, I'm just wondering if it's fair to still call it an "identity". We still respond to our name(s) etc
Avatar
it's like when derealisation depersonalisation and dissociated identity and everything else just dissociates
Avatar
Avatar
Unfastened Belts
Yeah that's definitely how he says it, I'm just wondering if it's fair to still call it an "identity". We still respond to our name(s) etc
i was thinking a lot about what identity is what forms it and how it is created and i was thinking of writing it down or making a video about it at one point because it has a lot to do with did but also explains a lot about plurality in different forms and i think also can be about spirituality experiences in way you describe when i say new identity i don't mean identity in a way that people think about it in administrative or legal work it's all you identify with the beliefs and memories and everything in our system it's all so fluid and for example our host woke up recently and just couldn't recognise the ex from the photos that means that the relationship wasn't part of their identity anymore and i think in this way when you practice your framework you still would keep the feeling of who you are in the world but everything you believe might change
10:58 PM
so for example our host you know they are a big big mess
10:58 PM
they are polyfragmented
10:58 PM
but they all identify with the body and name
10:58 PM
but they have different memories and beliefs and experiences
10:58 PM
so the way they experience life and reality is different it's hard to describe
10:59 PM
i think what spirituality is describing as awakening when it's about drastically changing perspective on life it's when big changes in the fundamentals of identity happen but in the part that refers to the external world and things that you describe in the framework like feeling of having control
10:59 PM
we experience those drastic changes all the time but they are out of control
11:00 PM
and it's all unstable
11:00 PM
but this feeling of drastic change is something we experience every day
11:01 PM
and isn't in some spiritual paths one of the things of leaving who you are in the past?
11:01 PM
all your belongings family and everything about you
11:01 PM
a bit like there needs to be destruction before creation
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 11:04 PM
Let me attempt another "translation from Roger". The waking life experience is a (multidimensional?!) spectrum that reaches from "completely identified with our body and our thoughts" on one side to "consciousness (awareness + sense of aliveness) without contents". Consciousness can also experience dream states, light sleep states, or be completely "off" (in deep sleep, coma, death). Integration is coming to see yourself as both, a human body/mind organism as well as the "being(ness)" in which the life experience arises. There is no dissociation from the body, functional thoughts about the past and future are possible, just the "psychological attitude of resistance" is permanently absent. Sort of the "sweet spot" in the middle between complete identification and complete dissociation
Avatar
i understand this 100% now thank you
11:06 PM
and yes we experience it all the time and we can see them both separate
11:07 PM
i can see how this way of how he described integration can be helping with realising you don't have control
11:07 PM
because what you do is separate from what you experience as life
11:07 PM
so that part that experiences we started calling it witness because we that word it in one very nice song (edited)
Avatar
Avatar
Deleted User
i understand this 100% now thank you
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 11:08 PM
Can't tell if you're being sarcastic because I'm repeating myself for the 100th time 😄
11:09 PM
Yeah. He likes it to call it "witnessing" rather than "witness" haha
Avatar
no no
11:09 PM
i'm not sarcastic
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 11:09 PM
Phew haha
Avatar
this time it was very very clear
Avatar
im confused. i'm just gonna say that lol
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 11:10 PM
Nice 🙂
Avatar
did i tell you that when we were in that witness state we were seeing how switches happen
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 11:10 PM
Lol that's cool JSheer
Avatar
and it was this weird experience because that witness could see other identities
Avatar
Unfastened Belts 2/27/2021 11:10 PM
Kitkat told me that you "found the witness" but that's about it
Avatar
but when they tried to look at them they couldn't
11:10 PM
it was very pure form of being
11:10 PM
just observing no judgement or pain
Exported 100 message(s)
Timezone: UTC+0
Page 1 ... Page 135 ... Page 136 ... Page 137 ... Page 249